June 21, 2025:
Something to grouse about, for sure.
GREENWICH — A former New York Yankees third baseman won a jury verdict expected to total about $500,000 after suing his landlord William Grous for mold problems, pests and other issues in a leased Greenwich mansion.
Josh Donaldson filed the federal suit against the Lake Avenue property owner in 2022 after paying a $110,000 security deposit and leasing the 4,480-square-foot home for $55,000 per month. The jury in U.S. District Court in Connecticut issued its verdict Wednesday.
Now retired, the three-time All Star and American League Most Valuable Player in 2015 had been traded to the Yankees from the Minnesota Twins in March 2022. Donaldson and his partner, who was six months pregnant, and their 17-month-old daughter moved into the Greenwich house in April, the complaint says.
The house sits on about 4-1/2 acres, has five bedrooms and 4-1/2 baths and is appraised at about $2.4 million, according to court documents and the Greenwich assessor. [But it sold to Grous for $3.325 million in 2005 — Ed]
However, instead of the luxury home Donaldson and his partner expected, the house was rife with problems, including an ant infestation throughout the main floor, non-working showers, broken toilets, an "unsightly, unusable pool" littered with shards of tile and concrete from a botched repair job, and an infiltration of squirrels nesting above the ceiling in one bedroom, the complaint said.
Shortly after moving in, Donaldson's partner and their daughter both developed lung congestion and lingering coughs, the suit said. An environmental testing company's inspection on April 19 revealed "an extensive and widespread infestation" of chaetomium and aspergillus mold, both of which can cause serious health problems, the complaint said.
Donaldson, through his lawyer, demanded that Grous immediately return the home to "a fit and livable condition," the suit said. The landlord, however, did not fix the mold infestation and the lease was terminated in May, the complaint said. Grous refused to return the security deposit, which led Donaldson to seek relief in court, according to the suit.
The jury verdict issued Wednesday totaled about $331,000, including $82,393.76 for costs for substitute housing, moving, transportation and other expenses, $220,000 for the security deposit (the $110,000 that Donaldson paid is doubled under Connecticut law), $1,341.87 for out-of-pocket expenses and $27,500 for emotional harm, according to the verdict form.
Donaldson's attorney, Craig Cepler, said Friday that he anticipated a judge would award in excess of $170,000 in legal expenses, which would bring the total to about $500,000.
"We're evaluating an appeal," Grous' attorney, Philip Russell, said Friday ….
I’d say the jury has already evaluated the defendant’s appeal, and found it lacking.
7 Comments
And now the next chapter
Mr. Donaldson was finally awarded $722,845,37 this April, but unfortunately, his claim is behind the $2.5 million foreclosure suit against landlord Grous by Deutsche Bank; it will be years before he collects, if ever.
FWIW’s Legal Eagle, Gideon, tipped me off to this suit, by the way, and also included a very interesting list of other properties tangled up in foreclosure actions. I’m not certain where he got the list, so I can’t vouch for its accuracy, but I did spot-check some of the properties, selected at random, and they’re in play; might be some relative bargains here.
UPDATE: Few, if any of these properties are actively listed on the MLS — the owners have hunkered down and are going nowhere, and why should they? A lot of these cases are close a decade old, and the owners are still in possession)
Mortgage Foreclosures
• 176 Old Stone Bridge Rd – Deutsche Bank v. Hayes
• 23 Gregory Rd – Deutsche Bank v. Toscano (Start date, 2019 and continuing)
• 81 Strickland Rd – Wilmington Trust v. Green (This one was fired up in 2017 and is still going)
• 362 Davis Ave Unit 3 – Deutsche Bank v. Souliere
• 4 Driftway – U.S. Bank Trust v. Petersen
• 43 Maple Ave Units 1–4 – JPMorgan Chase v. Allen
• 44 Edgewood Ave – Deutsche Bank Trust v. Ribeiro
• 453 E. Putnam Ave Unit 3G – U.S. Bank v. Holland
• 67 Holly Hill Ln – Wilmington Trust v. 67 Holly Hill LLC
• 28 E. Lyon Farm Dr Unit 28 – Nationstar Mortgage v. Guilfoile
• 345 Round Hill Rd – JPMorgan Chase v. Ryder
• 7 Will Merry Ln – Wilmington Trust v. Brodsky
• 74 Glen Ridge Rd – Wilmington Savings Fund Society v. Pogosian
• 84 Pemberwick Rd – U.S. Bank Trust v. Gojani
• 9 Seton Ln – JPMorgan Chase v. Supp
• 928 Lake Ave – Deutsche Bank v. Grous
• 969 North St – Patriot Bank v. Altavista Investments LLC
• 6A Lockwood Dr – U.S. Bank v. Maze
• 30 Willowmere Avenue – JPMorgan Chase v. Amodeo
• 83 Lancer Rd South – Astoria Bank v. Olbrych
• 23 Carleton St – U.S. Bank v. McGuire
• 14 Highview Ave – Bank of New York Mellon v. Arsenault (Tax evader on his way to prison)
• 58 Tomac Ave – Wells Fargo v. Blinten