Are the cows at Oakridge Dairy in Ellington happy? That's the question behind a recent dispute between the family farm and national animal rights group.
But customers of Oakridge and its Modern Milkman delivery service will no longer be reading website content about the emotional state of the dairy’s herd of 3,000 cows. After criticism from animal rights group PETA, the dairy has taken down statements on its website describing its farm as “an optimal living habitat” for the bovines.
“We just want to avoid further drama,” said Oakridge CEO Seth Bahler, the fifth generation of his family to run the dairy operation at 76 Jobs Hill Road.
…. The drama over Oakridge’s advertising kicked up last month when the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals publicly released a letter to the dairy alleging “false and misleading marketing claims.”
ENTER THE GREENS
Starting in 2023, Oakridge started turning its cows’ manure into biogas with a methane digester project, a form of renewable energy pitched as the “farm of the future.” In order to harvest that manure, cows must be kept indoors.
PETA plans to keep its webpage on the dairy up and continue its critiques of Oakridge’s operation, said PETA Associate Director Colin Henstock. “Calling it a family farm doesn't guarantee that they're not confining animals in factory-farm conditions,” he said.
Bahler countered that Oakridge’s cows are well cared for and get consistent veterinary treatment.
“I don’t like (PETA) saying that our cows aren't happy — I think they’re super, super happy,” Bahler said. “They’re an activist group that wants to end all animal agriculture, and I don’t agree with what their philosophy is.”
Now that Oakridge has removed its claims about the cows’ conditions, PETA is focused on other allegations around the Ellington dairy, Henstock said.
Farms with methane digesters often expand in size to increase production of biogas, worsening conditions for the animals, Henstock said. Some large farms also mean more methane is created in the form of cow burps, a potent greenhouse gas.
“Cow’s milk will always be bad for the environment no matter how a company tries to spin it,” Henstock said. “People who care about the environment and care about animals should really avoid all animal-derived milks and foods.”
Animal welfare added to green energy equation
The seeming clash between promised environmental benefits and the welfare of animals is an increasing concern reflecting a trend across the industry as the world seeks a sustainable path forward, said Daina Bray of the Law, Ethics & Animals Program at Yale Law School. Founded in 2019, the program looks at the intersection of environmental and animal issues from a legal perspective.
Another example of a clash is the shift from red meat to chicken and fish, which may save resources and alleviate the suffering of some animals, but result in the harming of many more smaller animals, Bray said.
“There are some examples of where sometimes humane treatment of animals and environmental protection may seem to be at odds,” Bray said. “But focusing on those clashes misses the larger point, which is that these intensive systems of animal agriculture like large dairy production facilities with biogas digesters … they have a whole array of externalized harms.”
Environmental scientists have found that biogas operations can cause pollution due to unwanted emissions of methane and ammonia, according to published studies.
Dairy leans on community support
As the debate over biogas and animal welfare continues, Bahler at Oakridge Dairy said that the Ellington community and his customers remain supportive. The dairy has not lost any business since the PETA campaign and received dozens of positive emails and comments on media stories, he said.
Farmers as a group feel embattled as costs and criticism of their work continue to rise, Bahler said. “Two percent of America is farming and trying to feed the world, and we’re under attack every single day. It’s frustrating.”
Then there’s Just Stop Oil. Combined, and the two groups share the same dark money master groups’ funding, we’ll have no heat, and we’ll walk to neighboring towns by shank’s mare, if we’re allowed to leave our villages at all. Of course, because we’ll have no food, we’ll be too weak to walk anywhere anyway. Paradise.